(954) 634-2652
In many cases, even if an invention has a low probability of obtaining a utility patent based on the results of a patent search, the business or inventor wants to develop the concept further. In those cases, a provisional patent application (PPA) may serve as a strategic tool for inventors and businesses. This article discusses how to leverage the benefits of a PPA to provide temporary protection and strategic advantages without the significant investment required for a full utility non-provisional patent application.
I. Provisional Patent Applications Establish an Early Filing Date
The United States follows a first-to-file system, which means that the first party to file a patent application for an invention has superior patent rights over others, regardless of who was the first to invent. This early filing date establishes priority, which can be critical in competitive industries where multiple parties may be working on similar innovations.
In the first-to-file system, a key advantage of filing a PPA is the ability to secure an early filing date while maintaining flexibility to further develop and refine the invention and determine whether pursuing a non-provisional patent is justified.
Additionally, under 35 U.S.C. § 102, public disclosure of an invention for more than one year prior to filing a patent application will bar patentability. In other words, if an invention is disclosed for more than one year before a patent application is filed, then the invention is barred from patent protection. Therefore, securing an early filing date is crucial to avoid potential loss of patent rights due to prolonged disclosure.
II. Provisional Patent Applications Can Help Validate Potential Commercial Success
A PPA allows an inventor to market their invention with the designation “patent pending.” This status can enhance the perceived value of the invention, attract potential investors or partners, and deter potential competitors from entering the same space. Importantly, this marketing benefit comes at a lower cost compared to the full expense of a non-provisional patent application.
III. Provisional Patent Applications Allow for Development of Patentable Subject Matter
During the product development process after filing a PPA, inventors may identify additional patentable elements that can strengthen the non-provisional application and broaden the scope of protection. For example, during the product development stage, an inventor may add features or make additional discoveries that enhance the effectiveness of the product, which may also increase the probability of obtaining a patent on the invention. In this way, provisional patent applications may help to increase the probability of obtaining a patent if additional matter is discovered during the development process.
IV. Cost-Effectiveness of the Provisional Patent Application
For inventions with a low likelihood of obtaining a utility patent, the cost-effectiveness of a PPA can be particularly advantageous. A provisional patent application is typically less costly than a non-provisional application. This is because a provisional patent application has fewer formal filing requirements, may take less patent attorney time to draft, and has lower USPTO fees associated with it compared to a non-provisional application.
V. Provisional Patent Applications to Evaluate Financial Risk
The United States Patent and Trademark Office never substantively examines a provisional patent application unless a non-provisional application claiming the benefit of the provisional patent application is filed within one year of the filing date of the provisional patent application. During the one-year period, if the invention proves to lack commercial traction or technological viability, the inventor can abandon the pursuit without incurring further costs. On the other hand, if the invention proves successful, the monetary risk of filing a non-provisional patent application is outweighed by the potential benefits of obtaining a patent to lock out competition and secure market exclusivity. Thus, the provisional patent application provides an opportunity to safely explore commercial viability without committing to the more substantial costs associated with a full non-provisional patent application, and without losing the potential for obtaining a patent monopoly on the invention.
VI. Be Cautious When Drafting a Provisional Patent Application
To fully capitalize on the benefits of a PPA, it is essential to draft the application with sufficient detail and clarity. The PPA should thoroughly describe the invention, including variations and potential applications, to provide a solid foundation for a future non-provisional application if warranted. A poorly drafted PPA could undermine future patent efforts by failing to provide adequate support for claims in a subsequent utility patent.
In conclusion, when an invention has a low probability of securing a utility patent, a provisional patent application can be an effective strategy to preserve rights, test market viability, and provide a strategic business advantage. Additionally, even if an invention is initially given a low probability of obtaining a patent, it may be granted patent protection, especially if additional elements are developed during the product development stage. Thoughtful preparation and proper documentation are key to maximizing its potential benefits while managing costs effectively.
Depending on your business strategy, filing a provisional patent application may be the best option for your business. However, the provisional patent application does have certain limitations. Click HERE to learn more about Derek Fahey, who wrote this article.
wordpress theme by initheme.com